Monday, 10 March 2014

Orchids; The masters of floral deception



Orchids are well known to be the masters of floral deception, with up to one third of all species completely lacking floral rewards such as nectar or harvestable pollen (Internicola and Harder, 2012). Generalised food deception (GFD) is the most common mechanism utilized by orchids to attract pollinators (Peter and Johnson, 2013), and operates by using a pollinator's instinctive expectations of a rewarding flower, and copying it. Orchids use sweet scents, bright contrasting colours and petal patterns which trigger powerful food seeking behaviors in pollinators, to allure them into their flowers (Peter and Johnson, 2013).
Internicola and Harder (2012) describe how although deceptive orchid species pose very little competition to rewarding species, they have developed adaptations for successful reproduction;  
  •  Flowering early in the season, which avoids competition with rewarding species and exploits naive pollinators (pollinators which are young and inexperienced).
  • Flowering for extended periods, which maximizes the chance of pollination when faced with infrequent visits and experienced pollinators.
Although orchids can reproduce successfully when employing GFD, they are very restricted. For example a deceptive orchid species can only exist as a few individuals over a large area to reduce the risk of associative learning (the ability a pollinator to remember, and avoid reward lacking species). After investigating associative learning between Calypso bulbosa and bumble-bees, Internicola and Harder (2012) discovered that while associative learning had severe consequences for most deceptive orchids, it had a limited effect on deceptive species that were specifically mimicking a co-occuring rewarding species. It is assumed that overall, the bumble-bees associated that particular morphology of flower with a reward; after visiting a rewarding species after a deceptive species, the bumble-bee was left with no negative associations. This provides evidence supporting that the use of GFD in orchids is far more successful in mimics than general deceptionists, due to positive associative learning, resulting in continued visitation from pollinators.

Calypso bulbosa flowers, photographed by Magnus Manske




Wednesday, 5 March 2014

The difference between mimicry and deception

Mimicry and deception in plants can be attributed to a range of traits and behaviors, which are very diverse across all species. Depczynski and Gagliano (2013) define forms of deception as having an increased evolutionary fitness through gaining a benefit, and or avoiding a loss. An example of deception is a flower that tricks pollinators into thinking it has nectar; the flower is essentially pollinated for free. The orchid (Eulophia speciosa) pictured below demonstrates features that pollinators commonly associate with rewards, such as nectar. Scent, colour, shape and petal patterns can all contribute to persuading a pollinator into the flower, by convincing them that a reward lies within.















Adapted from Peter and Johnson 2013
Depczynski and Gagliano (2013) also describe mimicry as a form of deception whereby a species models its traits, behavior or appearance on another successful species. Mimicry is demonstrated in the image below, with species (b) a nectar bearing iris (Watsonia lepida), and species (a) a mimicking orchid (Disa pulchra). The iris is known by pollinators to produce nectar, hence they associate its appearance with a reward and visit it frequently. The orchid however, does not produce nectar, and instead tricks the pollinators into visiting by pretending to be an iris. 

Adapted from Jersakova et al. 2012






Although reward producing species have a much higher pollination rate than the deceptive species, they exhibit a much higher species diversity. Many deceptive species have both male and female reproductive parts and run the risk of self pollination, an issue that the species seem to have overcome. Peter and Johnson (2013) have theorized that once a pollinator has been fooled by a deceptive species, it leaves the plant and moves onto another, thereby eliminating the risk of self pollination.